
[Lecture] How to break populist parties’ appeal? An experimental evaluation of communication counter-strategies (ActiveLab)
Right-wing populist parties have become a major challenge to democracies worldwide. How can mainstream parties counter their appeal? While prior research has focused on the drivers of populist support, much less is known about how to counter right-wing populist rhetoric. We test four communication counter-strategies that target core elements of right-wing populist appeals: (i) undermining populists’ claims to democratic credibility, (ii) promoting inclusive in-group identity to counter exclusionary narratives, (iii) highlighting their performance legitimacy, and (iv) emphasizing the procedural legitimacy of mainstream parties. Drawing on real-world party communications from social media, manifestos, and press releases, we created 170 experimental treatments (posters and social media posts varying in format and complexity) to simulate how voters encounter political messages in everyday life. In a large-scale survey experiment with over 24,000 respondents in Germany, messages undermining right-wing populists’ democratic credibility prove most effective, particularly among citizens with high initial support for such parties.
Prof Petra Schleiter is the founding Director of the Centre for Democratic Resilience at the University of Oxford. With over 60 publications, her work has shaped scholarly and policy debates on democratic institutions, party competition, political behaviour, and policy reform. She regularly serves as an expert witness for policymakers and advised the Irish Citizens’ Assembly in 2018. She has held visiting fellowships at Sciences Po (2026), the Institute for Advanced Study in Berlin (2024-25), and the Constitution Unit at University College London (since 2015).
